1
The Pig and Tinder Box
from 835 Google reviews.
429 Peel St, Tamworth NSW 2340
Most reviewed · Updated October 2026
As of October 2026, the three most reviewed restaurants rated 4.0 or better in Tamworth, NSW on Common Praise are The Pig and Tinder Box (835 Google reviews at 4.3), Burger Urge (Tamworth) (696 Google reviews at 4.6) and Williamsburg at The Press (573 Google reviews at 4.5).
1
from 835 Google reviews.
429 Peel St, Tamworth NSW 2340
2
from 696 Google reviews.
395-401 Peel St, Tamworth NSW 2340
3
from 573 Google reviews.
4
from 540 Google reviews.
331 Goonoo Goonoo Rd, Tamworth NSW 2340
5
from 449 Google reviews.
6
from 406 Google reviews.
15 Fitzroy St, Tamworth NSW 2340
7
from 334 Google reviews.
73-75 Kable Ave, Tamworth NSW 2340
8
from 314 Google reviews.
253 Peel St, Tamworth NSW 2340
9
from 299 Google reviews.
293 Marius St, Tamworth NSW 2340
10
from 295 Google reviews.
583 Armidale Rd, Tamworth NSW 2340
11
from 286 Google reviews.
276 Peel St, Tamworth NSW 2340
12
from 238 Google reviews.
13
from 235 Google reviews.
146 Bridge St, Tamworth NSW 2340
14
from 199 Google reviews.
266 Peel St, Tamworth NSW 2340
15
from 182 Google reviews.
164 Peel St, Tamworth NSW 2340
16
from 167 Google reviews.
265-267 Peel St, Tamworth NSW 2340
17
from 166 Google reviews.
11 White St, Tamworth NSW 2340
18
from 146 Google reviews.
19
from 132 Google reviews.
414 Peel St, Tamworth NSW 2340
20
from 111 Google reviews.
455 Peel St, Tamworth NSW 2340
21
from 103 Google reviews.
417-419 Peel St, Tamworth NSW 2340
22
from 78 Google reviews.
191 Goonoo Goonoo Rd, Tamworth NSW 2340
23
from 48 Google reviews.
178 Peel St, Tamworth NSW 2340
24
from 18 Google reviews.
Tamworth square, T30/432-452 Peel St
25
from 10 Google reviews.
23 Degance St, Tamworth NSW 2340
26
from 6 Google reviews.
Common Praise compared 26 restaurants in Tamworth, NSW, with 6,866 Google reviews between them. Of these, 26 meet this list's method. The median rating is 4.5 from a median of 217 reviews.
Of the restaurants compared, the most reviewed is The Pig and Tinder Box, with 835 Google reviews at 4.3.
Businesses rated 4.0 or better are ranked by how many Google reviews they have. Ties go to the higher rating.
Many reviews show a business is busy and well known, not that it is the right fit for your job.