1
Carah's Cakes & Pies
from 350 Google reviews.
63 Keppel St, Bathurst NSW 2795
Most reviewed · Updated October 2026
The bakeries of Bathurst
As of October 2026, the three most reviewed bakeries rated 4.0 or better in Bathurst, NSW on Common Praise are Carah's Cakes & Pies (350 Google reviews at 4.3), Bernard's Bakery (258 Google reviews at 4.3) and The Cheesecake Shop Bathurst (132 Google reviews at 4.8).
- Bakeries compared
- 8
- Google reviews
- 882
- Median rating
- 4.3
The bakeries of Bathurst: the top 6
2
Bernard's Bakery
from 258 Google reviews.
97 George St, Bathurst NSW 2795
3
The Cheesecake Shop Bathurst
from 132 Google reviews.
35 William St, Bathurst NSW 2795
4
Trinity Heights Bakehouse
from 30 Google reviews.
13 Marsden Ln, Kelso NSW 2795
5
Muffin Break Bathurst
from 28 Google reviews.
121 Howick St, Bathurst NSW 2795
6
Panorama Hot Bread Shop
from 17 Google reviews.
92A William St, Bathurst NSW 2795
Common Praise compared 8 bakeries in Bathurst, NSW, with 882 Google reviews between them. Of these, 6 meet this list's method. The median rating is 4.3 from a median of 34 reviews.
Of the bakeries compared, the most reviewed is Carah's Cakes & Pies, with 350 Google reviews at 4.3.
How this list is ranked
Businesses rated 4.0 or better are ranked by how many Google reviews they have. Ties go to the higher rating.
Many reviews show a business is busy and well known, not that it is the right fit for your job.
Questions
- Which bakeries in Bathurst, NSW have the most Google reviews?
- As of October 2026, the three most reviewed bakeries rated 4.0 or better in Bathurst, NSW on Common Praise are Carah's Cakes & Pies (350 Google reviews at 4.3), Bernard's Bakery (258 Google reviews at 4.3) and The Cheesecake Shop Bathurst (132 Google reviews at 4.8).
- How does Common Praise rank bakeries in Bathurst, NSW?
- Businesses rated 4.0 or better are ranked by how many Google reviews they have. Ties go to the higher rating. Many reviews show a business is busy and well known, not that it is the right fit for your job.
- How many bakeries in Bathurst, NSW did Common Praise compare?
- Common Praise compared 8 bakeries in Bathurst, NSW, with 882 Google reviews between them. Of these, 6 meet this list's method. The median rating is 4.3 from a median of 34 reviews.
- Can a business pay to be listed or to rank higher?
- No. Every business is ranked by the same published method, and no business can pay to be listed or to move up.