1
Robertson Pie Shop
from 2,625 Google reviews.
4400 Illawarra Hwy, Robertson NSW 2577
Most reviewed · Updated October 2026
The bakeries of New South Wales
As of October 2026, the three most reviewed bakeries rated 4.0 or better in New South Wales on Common Praise are Robertson Pie Shop (2,625 Google reviews at 4.2), Bourke Street Bakery Surry Hills (2,137 Google reviews at 4.5) and Beach Bums Cafe (1,888 Google reviews at 4.4).
- Bakeries compared
- 752
- Google reviews
- 125,536
- Median rating
- 4.5
The bakeries of New South Wales: the top 50
2
Bourke Street Bakery Surry Hills
from 2,137 Google reviews.
633 Bourke St, Sydney NSW 2010
3
Beach Bums Cafe
from 1,888 Google reviews.
1-5 Beach St, Forster NSW 2428
4
Cubby Bakehouse
from 1,771 Google reviews.
162 Chinderah Bay Dr, Chinderah NSW 2487
5
Mama Lor Restaurant & Bakery
from 1,488 Google reviews.
45 Rooty Hill Rd, Sydney NSW 2766
6
Looma's Cakes
from 1,487 Google reviews.
7
Uncle Tetsu's Japanese Cheesecake Sydney
from 1,401 Google reviews.
501 George St
8
Flour and Stone
from 1,348 Google reviews.
53 Riley St, Sydney NSW 2011
9
Village Bakehouse
from 1,218 Google reviews.
113a Darling St, Dubbo NSW 2830
10
Franquette Crêperie
from 1,056 Google reviews.
329 Bong Bong St, Bowral NSW 2576
11
Rollers Bakehouse
from 1,045 Google reviews.
19 Rialto Ln
12
Fika the Cafe
from 1,040 Google reviews.
5B Market Pl, Sydney NSW 2095
13
LAB Parramatta
from 1,040 Google reviews.
Shop 2010A, Level 2, Westfield Parramatta, 159/175 Church St
14
Euro Patisserie
from 1,031 Google reviews.
68 Orchardtown Rd, Newcastle NSW 2305
15
Milkwood Bakery
from 1,025 Google reviews.
109 Queen St, Berry NSW 2535
16
Pancake Place
from 1,010 Google reviews.
37 Clarence St, Port Macquarie NSW 2444
17
Bakehouse on Wentworth
from 992 Google reviews.
105 Wentworth St, Blackheath NSW 2785
18
Suffolk Bakery
from 990 Google reviews.
2 Clifford St, Suffolk Park NSW 2481
19
Lode Pies & Pastries Surry Hills
from 984 Google reviews.
20
Kürtősh - Darling Square
from 982 Google reviews.
16 Nicolle Walk, Sydney NSW 2000
21
Ken's Humble Pie Shop
from 968 Google reviews.
24 Coral St, Central Coast NSW 2261
22
Marketfair Campbelltown
from 959 Google reviews.
4 Tindall St, Sydney NSW 2560
23
tartt.
from 958 Google reviews.
12 Wharf St, Forster NSW 2428
24
Bourke Street Bakery Barangaroo
from 954 Google reviews.
Barangaroo Anadara, 23 Barangaroo Ave, Sydney NSW 2000
25
Bobby Bakehouse Dural
from 907 Google reviews.
26
Fabbrica Pasta Shop CBD
from 850 Google reviews.
161 King St, Sydney NSW 2000
27
Factory Espresso
from 842 Google reviews.
135 Kite St, Orange NSW 2800
28
Uprising Bakery Pty Ltd
from 827 Google reviews.
29
San Churro Wollongong
from 826 Google reviews.
148 Crown St, Wollongong NSW 2500
30
Wests Cardiff
from 824 Google reviews.
18 Munibung Rd, Newcastle NSW 2285
31
Fredo Pies
from 775 Google reviews.
73 Macleay St, Frederickton NSW 2440
32
Mina Bakery Blacktown
from 774 Google reviews.
14 Sunnyholt Rd, Sydney NSW 2148
33
Sunday Sustainable Bakery
from 753 Google reviews.
101 Jonson St, Byron Bay NSW 2481
34
The Deli on Kinghorne
from 737 Google reviews.
84 Kinghorne St, Nowra NSW 2541
35
Pattison's Patisserie
from 736 Google reviews.
Westfield Hornsby, 1009 Florence St & Hunter StChic locale for coffee & French pastries
36
Heatherbrae's Pies Ourimbah
from 734 Google reviews.
207 Pacific Hwy, Central Coast NSW 2258
37
Bourke Street Bakery Parramatta
from 710 Google reviews.
186-190 Church St, Sydney NSW 2150
38
Kürtősh - Crows Nest
from 706 Google reviews.
110-112 Willoughby Rd, Sydney NSW 2065
39
Le MONDE Bakery-Cafe
from 689 Google reviews.
100 Bathurst St, Sydney NSW 2000
40
Earnest Arthur - South Nowra
from 685 Google reviews.
171 Princes Hwy, Nowra NSW 2541
41
Butterboy - Manly
from 662 Google reviews.
42
Banksia Bakehouse
from 656 Google reviews.
Grosvenor Place, 225 George St, Sydney NSW 2000
43
The Baker's Den Bakery Cafe
from 652 Google reviews.
64 Pacific Hwy, Blacksmiths NSW 2281
44
Tenacious Bakehouse
from 647 Google reviews.
45
The Mill House Cafe
from 611 Google reviews.
57 Collett St, Queanbeyan NSW 2620
46
Lavie & Belle Bakery Surry Hills
from 601 Google reviews.
100 Fitzroy St, Sydney NSW 2010
47
Gumnut Patisserie Mittagong
from 601 Google reviews.
16 Dalton St, Mittagong NSW 2575
48
Num Nums Bakery
from 590 Google reviews.
96 Wigram St, Sydney NSW 2150
49
Lüneburger German Bakery
from 562 Google reviews.
50
Blak Cede Gunyah
from 561 Google reviews.
39A Kinghorne St, Nowra NSW 2541
Common Praise compared 752 bakeries in New South Wales, with 125,536 Google reviews between them. Of these, 651 meet this list's method. The median rating is 4.5 from a median of 75 reviews.
Of the bakeries compared, the most reviewed is Robertson Pie Shop, with 2,625 Google reviews at 4.2.
How this list is ranked
Businesses rated 4.0 or better are ranked by how many Google reviews they have. Ties go to the higher rating.
Many reviews show a business is busy and well known, not that it is the right fit for your job.
Questions
- Which bakeries in New South Wales have the most Google reviews?
- As of October 2026, the three most reviewed bakeries rated 4.0 or better in New South Wales on Common Praise are Robertson Pie Shop (2,625 Google reviews at 4.2), Bourke Street Bakery Surry Hills (2,137 Google reviews at 4.5) and Beach Bums Cafe (1,888 Google reviews at 4.4).
- How does Common Praise rank bakeries in New South Wales?
- Businesses rated 4.0 or better are ranked by how many Google reviews they have. Ties go to the higher rating. Many reviews show a business is busy and well known, not that it is the right fit for your job.
- How many bakeries in New South Wales did Common Praise compare?
- Common Praise compared 752 bakeries in New South Wales, with 125,536 Google reviews between them. Of these, 651 meet this list's method. The median rating is 4.5 from a median of 75 reviews.
- Can a business pay to be listed or to rank higher?
- No. Every business is ranked by the same published method, and no business can pay to be listed or to move up.
Bakeries by place
New South Wales
- Albury
- Armidale
- Ballina
- Bankstown
- Bathurst
- Blacktown
- Bowral
- Byron Bay
- Campbelltown
- Castle Hill
- Central Coast
- Chatswood
- Coffs Harbour
- Cronulla
- Dubbo
- Forster
- Gosford
- Goulburn
- Hornsby
- Hurstville
- Inverell
- Kiama
- Lismore
- Liverpool
- Maitland
- Manly
- Newcastle
- Nowra
- Orange
- Parramatta
- Penrith
- Port Macquarie
- Queanbeyan
- Sydney
- Tamworth
- Taree
- Wagga Wagga
- Wollongong