1
The Icky Sticky Patisserie
from 464 Google reviews.
Most reviewed · Updated October 2026
The bakeries of Maitland
As of October 2026, the three most reviewed bakeries rated 4.0 or better in Maitland, NSW on Common Praise are The Icky Sticky Patisserie (464 Google reviews at 4.5), M&M Bakehouse Rutherford (434 Google reviews at 4.8) and Blakeney's Pies (208 Google reviews at 4.6).
- Bakeries compared
- 25
- Google reviews
- 2,788
- Median rating
- 4.7
The bakeries of Maitland: the top 24
2
M&M Bakehouse Rutherford
from 434 Google reviews.
15 North Mall, Maitland NSW 2320
3
Blakeney's Pies
from 208 Google reviews.
52 Melbourne St, Maitland NSW 2323
4
Heddon Greta Bakehouse
from 193 Google reviews.
18 Main Rd, Heddon Greta NSW 2321
5
Morpeth Cottage Bakehouse
from 177 Google reviews.
151 Swan St, Maitland NSW 2321
6
Rutherford Bakehouse
from 154 Google reviews.
Rutherford Lpo, 22 East Mall, Maitland NSW 2320
7
East Maitland Bakehouse
from 123 Google reviews.
8
Bakers Delight Pender Place
from 115 Google reviews.
7 Ken Tubman Dr, Maitland NSW 2320
9
Niche on High
from 78 Google reviews.
10
Lady Blackbird Sourdough & Pastry
from 67 Google reviews.
414 High St, Maitland NSW 2320
11
Greenhills bakehouse
from 64 Google reviews.
The Pavillion, Newcastle NSW 2323
12
Time Traveller Coffee (formerly Bella & Co E/M)
from 56 Google reviews.
13
Village Walk Bakery
from 53 Google reviews.
119 Lawes St, Maitland NSW 2323
14
U1R Patisserie
from 46 Google reviews.
15
Sweet Moments by Design
from 37 Google reviews.
108 High St, Maitland NSW 2323
16
The Baker Bee
from 32 Google reviews.
17
AM's On Church
from 32 Google reviews.
11-13 Church St, Maitland NSW 2320
18
Franky & Co - Green Hills
from 32 Google reviews.
1 Molly Morgan Dr, Maitland NSW 2323
19
Van Gool Patisserie
from 30 Google reviews.
20
French Hot Bread Maitland
from 30 Google reviews.
328 High St, Maitland NSW 2320
21
Sammie Cakes
from 22 Google reviews.
22
Telarah Pies
from 6 Google reviews.
Kearsley Ln, Maitland NSW 2320
23
Celebrate with cake
from 4 Google reviews.
25 Ballard St, Maitland NSW 2320
24
Urban Mill Bakery
from 1 Google review.
Common Praise compared 25 bakeries in Maitland, NSW, with 2,788 Google reviews between them. Of these, 24 meet this list's method. The median rating is 4.7 from a median of 56 reviews.
Of the bakeries compared, the most reviewed is The Icky Sticky Patisserie, with 464 Google reviews at 4.5.
How this list is ranked
Businesses rated 4.0 or better are ranked by how many Google reviews they have. Ties go to the higher rating.
Many reviews show a business is busy and well known, not that it is the right fit for your job.
Questions
- Which bakeries in Maitland, NSW have the most Google reviews?
- As of October 2026, the three most reviewed bakeries rated 4.0 or better in Maitland, NSW on Common Praise are The Icky Sticky Patisserie (464 Google reviews at 4.5), M&M Bakehouse Rutherford (434 Google reviews at 4.8) and Blakeney's Pies (208 Google reviews at 4.6).
- How does Common Praise rank bakeries in Maitland, NSW?
- Businesses rated 4.0 or better are ranked by how many Google reviews they have. Ties go to the higher rating. Many reviews show a business is busy and well known, not that it is the right fit for your job.
- How many bakeries in Maitland, NSW did Common Praise compare?
- Common Praise compared 25 bakeries in Maitland, NSW, with 2,788 Google reviews between them. Of these, 24 meet this list's method. The median rating is 4.7 from a median of 56 reviews.
- Can a business pay to be listed or to rank higher?
- No. Every business is ranked by the same published method, and no business can pay to be listed or to move up.