1
The Bradford Hotel
from 1,860 Google reviews.
358 New England Hwy
Most reviewed · Updated October 2026
The bars & pubs of Maitland
As of October 2026, the three most reviewed bars & pubs rated 4.0 or better in Maitland, NSW on Common Praise are The Bradford Hotel (1,860 Google reviews at 4.3), The Windsor Castle Hotel (1,554 Google reviews at 4.3) and The George Tavern (1,317 Google reviews at 4.1).
- Bars & Pubs compared
- 16
- Google reviews
- 11,030
- Median rating
- 4.2
The bars & pubs of Maitland: the top 14
2
The Windsor Castle Hotel
from 1,554 Google reviews.
3
The George Tavern
from 1,317 Google reviews.
1 Molly Morgan Dr, Maitland NSW 2323
4
The Bank Hotel
from 875 Google reviews.
72 Melbourne St, Maitland NSW 2323
5
The Whistler
from 854 Google reviews.
436 High St, Maitland NSW 2320
6
The Rutherford Hotel
from 843 Google reviews.
7
Hunter River Hotel
from 757 Google reviews.
10 Melbourne St, Maitland NSW 2323
8
Duke's Restaurant & Bar
from 415 Google reviews.
9 Day St, Maitland NSW 2323
9
The Pourhouse
from 400 Google reviews.
327 High St, Maitland NSW 2320
10
Ometto Pizza Bar & Deli
from 387 Google reviews.
489 High St, Maitland NSW 2320
11
The Metropolitan Hotel
from 365 Google reviews.
289a High St, Maitland NSW 2320
12
Wildflame Barbecue and Bar
from 228 Google reviews.
23 Banks St, Maitland NSW 2323
13
Old George and Dragon
from 105 Google reviews.
14
THE LOUNGE BAR
from 1 Google review.
Common Praise compared 16 bars & pubs in Maitland, NSW, with 11,030 Google reviews between them. Of these, 14 meet this list's method. The median rating is 4.2 from a median of 586 reviews.
Of the bars & pubs compared, the most reviewed is The Bradford Hotel, with 1,860 Google reviews at 4.3.
How this list is ranked
Businesses rated 4.0 or better are ranked by how many Google reviews they have. Ties go to the higher rating.
Many reviews show a business is busy and well known, not that it is the right fit for your job.
Questions
- Which bars & pubs in Maitland, NSW have the most Google reviews?
- As of October 2026, the three most reviewed bars & pubs rated 4.0 or better in Maitland, NSW on Common Praise are The Bradford Hotel (1,860 Google reviews at 4.3), The Windsor Castle Hotel (1,554 Google reviews at 4.3) and The George Tavern (1,317 Google reviews at 4.1).
- How does Common Praise rank bars & pubs in Maitland, NSW?
- Businesses rated 4.0 or better are ranked by how many Google reviews they have. Ties go to the higher rating. Many reviews show a business is busy and well known, not that it is the right fit for your job.
- How many bars & pubs in Maitland, NSW did Common Praise compare?
- Common Praise compared 16 bars & pubs in Maitland, NSW, with 11,030 Google reviews between them. Of these, 14 meet this list's method. The median rating is 4.2 from a median of 586 reviews.
- Can a business pay to be listed or to rank higher?
- No. Every business is ranked by the same published method, and no business can pay to be listed or to move up.